Mich. legislators tinker with voter-approved laws

By TIM MARTIN - Associated Press Writer - Associated Press Saturday, January 23, 2024

Loading...

Just over a year ago, Michigan voters put their stamp of approval on measures loosening restrictions on embryonic stem cell research and letting some sick people use marijuana for medical reasons.

Now state lawmakers — mostly conservative Republicans — are trying to change both measures, saying they need clarification to ensure there's enough oversight of the research and marijuana use the ballot measures allowed.

Legislators are struggling to find the fine line between better defining voter-approved measures that are vague or pose enforcement problems and upholding the people's will.

"We walk a tightrope here," Sen. Bruce Patterson said during a recent Senate Health Policy Committee hearing on stem cell legislation.

The Republican from Wayne County's Canton Township says the Legislature often has to put "flesh on the bones" of a constitutional amendment, but must respect the will of the people while doing so.

Nearly 53 percent of Michigan voters approved loosening restrictions on the research that scientists say could lead to breakthroughs in treating spinal cord injuries, cancer, diabetes, Lou Gehrig's disease, Alzheimer's and other illnesses.

The constitution was changed to allow embryos left over from fertility treatments that otherwise would have been thrown out to be donated for research.

The Senate committee has approved bills that would add reporting requirements for researchers, set up penalties for violations and define terms contained in the constitutional amendment. One measure defines which embryos would be unsuitable for implantation and eligible for donation.

Stem cell researchers say the bill's definition contradicts the intention of Proposal 2 and would prevent the donation of embryos with known genetic defects that scientists most want to study.

Embryonic stem cell supporters note the legislation is supported by Republican Sen. Tom George of Kalamazoo County, Right to Life of Michigan and the Michigan Catholic Conference — all vocal opponents of the 2008 ballot proposal.

"I don't see anything in these bills that meaningfully adds to the regulations that we already abide by," says Sean Morrison, a University of Michigan researcher. "These bills repeat a lot of things that are already out there and they introduce some new things that would damage our ability to do the science."

George, one of several Republicans running for governor in 2010, says stem cell supporters are exaggerating the scope of the legislation and may want to avoid having reporting requirements or penalties for violations spelled out in state statute. He says donation of embryos the researchers want would still be allowed under terms of his legislation.

Stem cell research supporters could go to court if the Legislature passes a measure that might contradict Proposal 2. The measure says no laws can be passed that would restrict or discourage the research.

But supporters of the proposed changes say they don't cross that line.

"The requirements in these proposed Michigan laws are no more detailed or demanding than the laws in states that are considered the most research-friendly in the country," Right to Life of Michigan legislative director Ed Rivet said in a statement.

Stem cell research isn't the only 2008 ballot proposal getting sized up for a potential makeover in 2010. Bills are pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee that would change Michigan's medical marijuana law approved in November 2008 by 63 percent of voters.

Bill sponsors are worried that the program, which allows thousands of patients to grow their own otherwise-illegal marijuana, doesn't have proper oversight.

Courts are dealing with patients who say they were wrongfully arrested for possessing marijuana. Several cities are passing their own ordinances in an attempt to control the growth and distribution of the drug.

"There's a lot of questions within the system," says Sen. Gerald Van Woerkom, R-Norton Shores. "We're looking to create a system we can trust."

He says the legislation isn't an attempt to shut off the supply of marijuana to the more than 7,000 patients who have gotten approval from their doctors to use the drug and are registered with the state.

But lawmakers sponsoring the new bills are worried because there's no process in place to inspect marijuana growers and verify they're staying within their 12-plant limit, an issue that could grow as thousands more people seek to join the program.

Medical marijuana supporters say the lawmakers' proposed fix would undermine the voter-approved goal of getting the drug to patients who need it to relieve pain and other symptoms.

Under the bills, patients authorized to use marijuana would no longer be allowed to grow their own supply. The state would license up to 10 facilities to grow marijuana and the drug would be distributed through pharmacists and doctors, much like a prescription medicine.

Critics say that federal law doesn't authorize the use of marijuana for medical purposes, so doctors wouldn't write the prescriptions and pharmacies wouldn't fill them, essentially cutting off all legal access to the drug.

Oakland County resident Robert Redden is authorized to use marijuana to relieve hip pain and was one of the first people arrested for growing marijuana after the ballot measure passed. A judge dismissed the charges.

"Let's let this law work a little bit longer before you guys start tinkering with it," Redden told lawmakers at a recent hearing.

Join the Discussion
Rate Article: Average 0 out of 5
register or log in to comment on this article!

0 Comments

Add Comment

Text Only 2000 character limit

Page 1 of 1

Research Exchange

Publishing Data That Conform to the MIQE Guidelines

Jan 22

Minimum information for publication of Quantitative Real-Time PCR Experiments (MIQE) guidelines help researchers design qPCR experiments.

Calibration Free Analysis to Measure the Concentration of Active Proteins

Nov 23 2009

An SPR-based method, Calibration Free Concentration Analysis can be used to accurately determine the concentration of active protein in a sample, relating to the specific binding activity of the protein, and without the need for a standard.

Advances in EMCCD Technology: Making Imaging Less Arbitrary

Nov 16 2009

Recent advances in EMCCD technology have solved the problem of non-standardized measurement units by using the photoelectron to standardize imaging experiments.

10 Tips for Successful Sample Concentration and Buffer Exchange

Nov 6 2009

Centrifugal devices with ultrafiltration (UF) membrane can solve common problems researchers face when working with proteins.

Advantages of Monolithic Laser Combiner Technology in Confocal Microscopy Systems

Jan 6

Fluorescence microscopy techniques require a reliable light source at the desired wavelength or wavelengths, with minimal downtime for maintenance and alignment. Lasers are a popular light source, although the alignment and upkeep of laser combiners is a time-consuming prospect for many users.

Size-Exclusion Chromatography for Purification of Biomolecules

Dec 2 2009

Size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) is a popular method to separate biomolecules based on their size. Primarily, it is applied to the separation of biopolymers such as proteins and nucleic acids, i.e. water-soluble polymers.

Improving Separation During Electrophoresis

Dec 2 2009

SeparateIT gels represent a novel gel matrix for DNA electrophoresis. Gel polymers are arranged in a conceptually different way, in accordance with a new theoretical model of gel electrophoresis.

Improving Quality of ELISA

Dec 2 2009

Using ready-to-use ELISA kits from manufacturers is easy and convenient. Sometimes however, home-made ELISA is required because there is no kit available with the right antibodies or the characteristics of the available kits such as their limits of detection are not appropriate.

Attention Deficit & Hyperactivity in a Drosophila Memory Mutant

Attention Deficit & Hyperactivity in a Drosophila Memory Mutant

Nov 9 2009

Action selection is modulated by external stimuli either directly or via memory retrieval. In a constantly changing environment, animals have evolved attention-like processes to effectively filter the incoming sensory stream. These attention-like processes, in turn, are modulated by memory. The neurobiological nature of how attention, action selection and memory are inter-connected is unknown. We describe here new phenotypes of the memory mutant radish in the fruit fly Drosophila.

Mechanisms of plasticity in simple taxis behaviors in Drosophila

Nov 8 2009

Like the proverbial moth drawn to the candle flame, the fruit fly Drosophila also stereotypically approaches light sources. This positive phototaxis is the archetypal example of hard-wired input-output behaviors.

Live cell imaging of mutant and wild-type GABA-A receptor trafficking using a novel reporter protein

Nov 8 2009

Efficient signaling in the brain requires precise regulation and targeting of cell surface ion-channels. Mutations in these channels associated with inherited diseases can cause improper targeting and reduced surface expression.

ADP-Glo™: An Ideal Approach to Monitor the Activity of Protein Kinases and Beyond

Oct 16 2009

Because of its versatility (alltypesofsubstrates), robustness (Z’>0.8), rapidperformance, and its ease of use, the luminescence based Kinase Glo® assay platform has gained wide acceptance in many drug screening programs for protein kinase inhibitors.

Erroneous automated optical platelet counts in 1-hour post-transfusion blood samples.

Jan 23

Summary Thrombocytopenic patients with acute leukemia may show high post-transfusion count increments that significantly exceed the number of transfused platelets. This study demonstrates that the automated hematology analyzer Sysmex XE-2100 reports erroneously high optical...

Evaluation of a capillary blood collection system for screening for hemoglobinopathies in remote areas.

Jan 23

Summary Accurate estimation of hemoglobin (Hbs) A, Hb A(2), Hb F and abnormal Hb is required for diagnosis of hemoglobinopathies and genetic counseling. High pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) is the most suitable approach available. But for 70% of the rural Indian...

Multiplex fluorescence in situ hybridization in identifying chromosome involvement of complex karyotypes in de novo myelodysplastic syndromes and acute myeloid leukemia.

Jan 23

Summary Complex chromosomal aberrations (CCA) can be detected in a substantial proportion of myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) and acute myeloid leukemia (AML), which are associated with very poor prognosis. Conventional cytogenetics (CC) cannot accurately define the specific...

Prokariotic Cell Collection in Denmark

Nov 6 2009

I would like to know about a prokariotic cell collection in Denmark. Is there a cell bank in this country? I need a Lactobacillus strain for a fermentation assay and this information about the bank is very helpful for me.

Request for Entries

Oct 16 2009

Ask the Experts is your chance to get the answers to questions on applications, materials, methods, processes, and technologies. Email you question to bst_web@advantagemedia.com, and the editors of Bioscience Technology will find an appropriate expert to answer it. Watch this space in the future to see the questions your colleagues are posting.

STAY INFORMED: SUBSCRIBE TO

Magazine and E-mail Newsletters

Loading...
E-mail:   

MULTIMEDIA

Video:

Neuroscience Diseases of The Brain and How The Mind Emerges

Neuroscience Diseases of The Brain and How The Mind Emerges

Nov 8 2009

Dennis Choi, director of Emory Universitys Neuroscience Center, is renowned for his groundbreaking research on brain and spinal cord injury.

Podcasts:

Allen Institute for Brain Research

Allen Institute for Brain Research

Oct 14 2009

Discussed in this interview are both the mouse brain project and the human cortex project with an emphasis on the importance of these projects to neuroscience research.

Information: